Towards better social and environmental impact reporting

by Carol A Adams

Main points:

  • Standards and guidance concerned with reporting on social and environmental issues are coalescing
  • The UK Government seeks to increase social and environmental impact reporting
  • The UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) provide an impetus for impact reporting
  • Approaches to the SDGs aligned with reporting frameworks and governance approaches provide a means to address sustainable development issues through strategy to create value
  • The UK Financial Reporting Council’s new Guidance on the Strategic Report and revised Corporate Governance Code provide limited additional impetus for an increased focus on impact reporting.

The UK government’s Taskforce charged with implementing recommendations to grow a culture of social impact investing has today released the findings of its Better Reporting work stream.  The report draws on input from the Taskforce’s Better Reporting working group, 92 responses to a call for evidence, 13 interviews with experts and desk research.

Whilst the Taskforce was established by the UK Government it has global relevance due to the globalisation of business and investment activities.

The report notes that reporting standards and practice are coalescing and calls for this to continue emphasising the need for a principles-based approach and transparency.  The report calls for further coalescence noting that the majority of respondents feel the SDGs have a role to play in this.

Key findings on the current reporting landscape are:

  • Sixteen reporting approaches were identified including those of the CDSB, Global Reporting Initiative and the IIRC (integrated reporting) and UN Global Compact.
  • There is a lack of adequate assurance and verification processes for impact reporting which limits its usefulness to investors.
  • There is a lack of methodologies to measure social and environmental impact.
  • Insufficient linkage is made between material issues and strategy.
  • In the last 25 years non-financial reporting provisions around the world have increase from around 100 to around 1,000 (the Reporting Exchange)
  • The report notes that the CDSB, integrated reporting and TCFD recommendations call for similar processes and disclosures thereof.

On the last point, I’ve previously noted the strong alignment across these three approaches – whilst their emphasis differs, they can be used together.  The <IR> Framework is also compatible with developing a strategy to contribute to the SDGs and report thereon (see report on this here).

Inevitably some contributors objected to legislation to increase impact reporting on the grounds that it would inhibit innovation.  Legislation to creating a minimum level playing field would not do this and mandatory requirements which are enforced reporting remains insufficient and under-developed.

The next phase of this project will develop specific proposals on social and environmental impact reporting to inform the Taskforce’s recommendations to the UK Government in early 2019.

The Implementation Taskforce’s Better Reporting Working Group is led by Olivia Dickson and Paul Druckman, Non-Executive Directors of the Financial Reporting Council. A Deloitte team led by Sam Baker supported the work for this report.   The role of technology in increasing impact reporting is also being considered.


Let’s Talk Value: How Universities Create Value for Students, Staff and Society

Main points: Universities contribute to solving the world’s challenges and improving future workforce skills A focus on value for money, efficiency and outputs sells universities short Integrated reporting has improved university decision … [Continue reading]

Social impact, the Sustainable Development Goals and Integrated Reporting

by Carol A Adams Main points: Asset managers, Baillie Gifford, and asset owners, Cbus Superannuation Fund are seeking to report contribution to the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) Measuring and managing social impact and … [Continue reading]

UK FRC calls for consideration of climate change risk and importance of stakeholders to value creation

by Carol A Adams Main points: Acknowledgement that climate change presents risks for companies Recognition that stakeholders are important to the long-term success of a company Support for increasing integration of non-financial … [Continue reading]

ASX consultation on Corporate Governance Principles

by Carol A Adams Main points: 'Social licence to operate' is inappropriate as a frame for determining climate change and other sustainability risks Boards should identify sustainable development risks in their external environment … [Continue reading]

UK Green Finance Inquiry report concludes climate change risk reporting should be mandatory

by Carol A Adams Main points: Pension fund Trustees have a Fiduciary Duty to consider long term financial risks of climate change There's a lack of regulatory mechanisms in place to ensure climate change risks are incorporated into … [Continue reading]

Debate: Integrated reporting and accounting for sustainable development across generations by universities

by Carol A Adams This article aims to stimulate debate on how integrated thinking and reporting can contribute to value creation for university stakeholders and achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals. Universities have significant … [Continue reading]

Pension funds adopt strikingly different approaches to climate change risk

by Carol Adams Pension funds invest for the long term and scientists have concluded that climate change poses a significant risk to all aspects of life, including water, food and energy security.  The implications for business are significant and … [Continue reading]

UK Green Finance Inquiry report released

by Carol A Adams Main points: Green investment levels have declined and are insufficient to meet legally binding carbon reduction targets Green bonds, carbon pricing, policy certainty and maintaining links with Europe are part of the … [Continue reading]

Pension funds and Defined Contribution members called to action on climate change

by Carol A Adams The Chair of the British Government's cross-party Environmental Audit Committee (EAC), Mary Creagh, has written to the Trustees of the country's top 25 pension funds asking some probing questions about climate change risks, … [Continue reading]