by Carol Adams
The International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) is developing profession-agnostic ethics and independence standards for sustainability assurance providers and sustainability reporters that is neutral with regard to sustainability reporting standards. I was asked to speak briefly at the start of a round table event in Sydney, one of four held globally. This is a welcome project and a few tweaks to Part 2 of the code on accountants in business could change the way accountants and businesses interact with sustainable development issues and help accelerate their incorporation in the training of accountants. These are the key issues I noted for consideration:
- Understanding and identifying greenwashing
- Information, or lack of it, influences decisions
- Understanding the science relevant to the information disclosed
- Limited assurance scopes and involvement in the preparation of information disclosed
- Understanding the sustainable development issues affecting the industry and company
- The need to involve sustainability professionals and scientists
Greenwashing
Part 1 of the code requires that a professional accountant “shall not knowingly be associated with the reports, returns, communications or other information where the accountant believes that the information:
- Contains a material false or misleading statement
- Contains statements that have been provided recklessly
- Omits or obscures required information where such omission or obscurity would be misleading.” (para R111.2)
With regard to sustainability assurance we need to consider this from the perspective of who has a stake in corporate sustainability information. It is broader than for financial reporting. To whom is the information misleading, provided recklessly or obscuring? Greenwashing is information which is misleading and obscuring to the full set of corporate stakeholders who have an interest in sustainability information. It may also be provided recklessly. There is a great deal of research conducted by accounting academics that highlights corporate greenwashing. For example, with respect to pollution incidents, my research has highlighted:
- Omission of material impacts on marine animal and human health
- Minimising/glossing over such impacts
- Reporting the fine or other direct financial consequence to a company (such as a fine) of an incident and not the indirect financial consequences or the impacts on the environment and people
- Twisting the science to suit the reporting organisation.
Similarly, where a reporting standard relies on judgment, for example to determine what is financially material, there is likely to be a tendency to maintain the status quo and continue not acknowledge risks that have hitherto have been ignored. We know from research that reporting of climate change risks is limited and often restricted to the risk of increased legislation with associated compliance costs.
Information, or lack of it, influences decisions
The code notes (200.5 A3) that the “more senior the position of professional accountants, the greater will be their ability …to influence policies, decisions made and actions taken by others involved with the employing organisations.”
Senior accountants and other professionals can influence what information is provided, and not provided, to senior management and the board with regard to sustainable development impacts and sustainability risks and opportunities. The code could play a role in raising the awareness of senior accountants in business of how sustainability information does and could further enhance decision making. A few tweaks to the wording of this section could underscore the importance of information on an organisation’s social and environmental impacts in decision making.
Limited assurance scopes and involvement in the preparation of information disclosed
Sustainability reporting and hence assurance is new relative to financial reporting. Research evidence shows that the sustainability assurance engagements primarily focus on quantified data, and less so on processes, systems and policies. Yet processes, systems and policies influence how decisions are made. Skeptism and integrity are important when considering acceptance of a limited scope engagement. The KPIs reported might be correct, but are they complete? The report reader needs to know whether information provided on the process of determining material information is credible. The assurance provider may be confident about the data in the scope of assurance, but become aware that there are omissions and misstatements in other areas.
The appropriateness of the common practices of assisting in gathering or determining the information disclosed or advising on data sources and internal controls (“pre-assurance” work) exists because the field is relatively new and organisations have skills gaps. But needs careful consideration from an independence perspective as the practice of sustainability assurance develops and increases.
Understanding the science and sustainable development context
The Code spells out the need for professional competence and due care. Any professional engaged in sustainability reporting or assurance must have at least a basic knowledge and understanding of sustainability, the issues pertinent to the industry, relevant global pronouncements and the science that influences selection of targets and assessment of performance. This applies to professional accountants too and could be explicit addressed in the code.
Letting “other” professionals in
The market for sustainability reporting assurance, whether mandatory or voluntary, will increase. IFAC research shows that assurance over sustainability reporting is increasing rapidly and “information disclosed in accordance with GRI Standards is assured more often than any other reporting framework or standard”. A range of skills are needed and a number of professions are involved in this work. No one profession should seek to dominate.
The round table discussions were confidential, so this post is limited to the points I raised at the start.



Thank you Carol. Valid points in scope and depth.
While your comments refer primarily to assurance in regard to ISAE3000 (limited and Reasonable), I would have expected your comments to include mention of Types 1 and 2 assurance under AA1000AS v3.
The two assurance standards are not the same and use of both provides complementary results.
Thank You Carol.
I agree with Mr. Frommer.
As you well wrote that “no one profession should seek to dominate” , my vision about the current situation is that IFRS Foundation, with its ISSB arm, is aware of others sustainability consultants and don’t want to share the growing market of sustainability assurance. Ten years ago, IFAC did’nt care about it at my knowledge. Since 2015, sustainability imperative is gradually becoming a world paradigm and I see that IFAC realized that, there is probably a good market with that. I hope that a more sustainable world will exclude competition between professionnals . Cooperation and complementarity shoudl be part of a wanted international sustainability reporting standard.
A good articulation of the issues as always thank you. I would also observe the interconnection between the themes you have here: i.e. a limited scope assurance engagement e.g. focussed on just the accuracy of data, is not likely to take into account the possibility of qualitative greenwashing statements as the assurance is only focussed on quantitative data. And where the assurance team does not include those with sufficient sustainability knowledge, they would not realise it was greenwashing even if they did look at it. As noted above, AA1000AS went around this circle years ago, in requiring the competencies of teams to be disclosed etc.