Assessing impacts, the starting point for sustainability reporting: GRI and ESRS comparison

by Carol Adams

Determining what to report is a first step in sustainability reporting and one of the more time-consuming parts of the process. The good news for GRI reporters who are also required to report using ESRS is that the starting point for both GRI Standards and European Reporting Standards (ESRS) is essentially the same – the assessment of impacts. Both sets of standards have very similar definitions of impact and set out almost identical steps to assessing impact materiality. 

ESRS 1 para 38 similarly states:

“…the starting point is the assessment of impacts… A sustainability impact may be financially material from inception or become financially material, when it could reasonably be expected to affect the undertaking’s financial position, financial performance, cash flows, its access to finance or cost of capital over the short-, medium- or long-term.” 

ESRS 1 para 38

The wording in GRI Standards is similar  – see GRI 1 Box 1 and the proposed update discussed by the Global Sustainability Standards Board (GSSB):

“…an organization’s impacts can result in its own risks and opportunities. These risks and opportunities can affect the organization’s business model or strategy and, consequently, its cash flows, access to finance, or cost of capital over the short, medium, or long term.” 

GRI 1 Box 1 proposed updated text

The steps in assessing impact materiality using GRI Standards and ESRS are set out below. GRI 3 provides substantial guidance to undertaking these steps which will be a useful additional resource to ESRS reporters.

GRI Standards – GRI 3 – Guidance to determine material topics Available hereESRS – Application requirements AR9 – double materiality Available here
Step 1. Understand the organization’s context… the organization creates an initial high-level overview of its activities and business relationships, the sustainability context in which these occur, and an overview of its stakeholders. (a) understanding of the context in relation to its impacts including its activities, business relationships, and stakeholders. 
Step 2. Identify actual and potential impacts…the organization identifies its actual and potential impacts on the economy, environment, and people, including impacts on their human rights, across the organization’s activities and business relationships.  (b) identification of actual and potential impacts both negative and positive… 
Step 3. Assess the significance of the impacts…the organization assesses the significance of its identified impacts to prioritize them. (c) assessment of the materiality of its actual and potential impacts and determination of the material matters. 
Step 4. Prioritize the most significant impacts for reporting…the organization prioritizes its impacts based on their significance. 
Steps in assessing impact materiality

The characteristics of impact severity are also very similar under both sets of Standards, with GRI 3 again providing substantial additional guidance.

GRI Standards – GRI 3 – Guidance to determine material topics ESRS – Application requirements AR10
Scale: how grave the impact is. (a) scale: how grave the negative impact is or how beneficial the positive impact is for people or the environment
Scope: how widespread the impact is…(b) scope: how widespread the negative or positive impacts are…
Irremediable character: how hard it is to counteract or make good the resulting harm.(c) irremediable character: whether and to what extent the negative impacts could be remediate
Characteristics of impact severity

The similarities in the starting point for sustainability reporting under both GRI Standards and ESRS are not surprising given that GRI and the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG) agreed at the outset to:

“to share technical expertise to co-construct new EU sustainability reporting standards and contribute to further global convergence”.

Note: This post is the author’s own work and does not represent an organisational or shared view.

Share this article

Speak Your Mind

*

Enter your email address to receive the latest posts