The SEC and short term profit v sustainability and corporate longevity

by Carol A Adams

Last week Paul Atkins, Trump appointee as Chair of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) criticised the EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and the Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) noting that they apply to US companies with operations in the EU and arguing they will result in costs being passed on to such companies. Atkins does not like, what the European Union refers to as “double materiality”. He takes the view that:

A focus on financial materiality means that disclosure requirements, corporate governance standards, and other regulations are aimed at interests of investors, who, after all, provide the capital to power the products, services, and jobs created by the corporation. 

GRI’s Global Sustainability Standards Board (GSSB) is of the view that most, if not all, of the significant impacts of an organisation will become financially material to organizations over time. There are numerous high profile cases of corporate negative impacts resulting in consumer boycotts, closing of operations, loss of revenue (through these and other consequences of significant negative impacts), fines and other costs. Identification of the risks and opportunities arising from impacts is relatively straight forward, while (financial) quantification, is much more challenging. 

A June 2025 GSSB paper sets out the GSSB’s position. The GSSB describes the relationship between an organisation’s most significant impacts (those that are required to be reported using GRI Standards) and its sustainability-related risks and opportunities. The primary objective of the proposed project (awaiting funding) is to provide guidance on the link between impacts, risks, and opportunities, building on existing definitions and guidance from GRI 1 and GRI 3, while connecting to established financial reporting practices set out in the IFRS Standards. 

Businesses that acknowledge the relationship between their significant impacts and risks and opportunities to investors are in a better position to develop a strategy to manage those impacts and their financial effects. 

The project of GRI’s independent multi-stakeholder standards board, the GSSB, is a contribution to the MOUs between the GRI/GSSB and the IFRS Foundation/ISSB. It will:

  • identify and describe the relationship between an organization’s most significant impacts and its sustainability-related risks and opportunities. This may result in amendments to the GRI Standards or separate guidance materials.
  • inform the GSSB’s relationship with other corporate reporting standard setters, particularly the ISSB and the International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSASB) on the global level as well as jurisdictional standard setters that are considering or already require disclosure of impacts on economy, environment, and people.

Atkins raises “significant concerns” with these EU Directives seeing them as a burden on U.S. companies “the costs of which are potentially passed on to American investors and customers”. The crux of his concern is that Europe is “pursuing ends that are unrelated to the economic success of companies and to the well-being of their shareholders” and he wants to see a focus on financial rather than double materiality. GRI’s GSSB takes the view that reporting on significant impacts has a place in the global reporting system, for all stakeholders including for investors, not least because of the connection between significant impacts, dependencies, risks and opportunities – see paper under development here.

Atkins finishes by saying:

President Trump calls America a “nation of builders.” Under my chairmanship, the SEC will encourage those builders, not suffocate them under red tape. Our goal is simple: to spark a golden age of financial innovation on U.S. soil.

Doing so, without considering the impacts corporations have on society and the environment is likely to backfire on companies beyond the short term and affect the availability of resources and relationships on which organisations depend in the longer term. It is also contrary to the ambitions of the UN in achieving the Sustainable Development Goals for the benefit of future generations.

Independent academic research related to these connections and issues is published in academic journals such as the Sustainability Accounting Management and Policy Journal.

A GRI + IFRS S approach, as in the EU, better positions companies and economies, not to mention their people and the environment, beyond the short term.

Share this article

Speak Your Mind

*

Enter your email address to receive the latest posts