by Carol A Adams
I’ve spent the last couple of days at the UNCTAD ISAR conference in Geneva where the focus has been on sustainability and SDG reporting. This is an important conference where regulators and others can share and learn from their approaches and experiences. Questions and comments from the audience and discussion with delegates however revealed that significant confusion remains about the future of sustainability reporting standard setting and the role of guidance and frameworks from various UN bodies.
Some national regulators have realised that implementing the forthcoming ISSB standards alone will not help them meet their commitments to the SDGs, nor will it meet all the needs of investors. Many are unaware that the GRI Standards set by the GSSB are developed through a rigorous process on a par with accounting standard setters. Others have developed regulation based on GRI Standards and the TCFD recommendations. Some are seeing the need for both GRI and ISSB Standards.
Whilst there is now only one key body, the ISSB, addressing the financial impact of sustainability on an organisation, there are several initiatives addressing the impact of the organisation on society and the environment. Whilst this underscores the importance of impact reporting, the disparity across these initiatives limits their combined effectiveness.
The various UN bodies have different approaches to encouraging voluntary disclosure of impacts on society and the environment. These UN bodies can rightly claim they own the SDGs and that their various initiatives have been important in increasing corporate accountability for social and environmental impacts. For example, I’m aware of the work of UNCTAD ISAR on corporate impacts going back to the 1980s. But it’s time for the disparity between these impact initiatives to be addressed. The initiatives are partially aligned and include subsets of issues and topics covered by GRI Standards, with some lack of consistency with GRI Standards on the calculation of indicators. They are frameworks or guidance that don’t go through the rigorous approach of a standard setter and so cannot be mandated by regulators.
How much more powerful would it be for these initiatives to align more closely with the GRI’s Standards? This would facilitate more jurisdictions adopting GRI Standards alongside the ISSB’s financial materiality standards. The European Commission has already adopted GRI Standards through EFRAG’s work, and other delegates, such as from Kenya also spoke of mandatory requirements based on GRI Standards. Jurisdictions represented at the UNCTAD ISAR conference see the importance of accountability and action by companies operating in their jurisdictions for their impacts on society and the environment. This is not a purpose of the ISSB Standards.
This process could start with UNCTAD, the UNGC, UNEP and UNDP encouraging their regulatory, corporate and public agency networks to use their respective guidance and tools to work towards impact reporting using the GRI Standards. This would assist in building capacity prior to mandatory enforcement of sustainability reporting. It would also lead to improvements in SDG reporting which is much needed according to KPMG’s 2022 survey of sustainability reporting. The survey shows an increase in both GRI and TCFD reporting, the latter of which will be further strengthened by the ISSB’s proposed IFRS S2 standard.
Participants stressed the importance of lesser developed countries having a voice, which UNCTAD ISAR provides. The need for sustainability reporting by SMEs was stressed repeatedly.




Hi Carol, I admire your comments on solving the so-called „double materiality “. To balance the arguments, you should publish the speech (and a summary of his additional comments) by Martin Moloney, Secretary-General, IOSCO, from today’s (Nov 3, 22) UNCTAD-ISAR session.
To me, a better approach to materiality confusion is to first separate objects from value. Perhaps this will be easier to understand as a standard and to implement.
To focus on object disclosure satisfies most the ESG disclosure, whereas value relates to financial reporting using market valuations, and such measures as currencies, „bitcoins“ and other estimates, like intangibles.
GRI has done a lot of work on the measurement of objects, perhaps not enough and in a balanced approach. (See my 3Ps*).
SASBs contribution was to break object attention by industries. The ISSB can integrate both for materiality emphasis.
*If you google „performance reporting objects” and hit images, the first image coming up explains it further –
or look at my book „IFRS and XBRL – how to improve Business Reporting through technology and object tracking “.
I am proud to have spent 10 years at the IFRS Foundation and been responsible for its commercial set-up. It is a pleasure to see what they have done with it.