Australian Treasury proposes mechanism for “sustainability standards” to be set from a financial materiality perspective

by Carol A Adams

Key points:

  • Proposed amendments to legislation to allow the Australian Accounting Standards Board (AASB) to set “sustainability standards” do not require that skills in sustainability are represented on the Board
  • Only the ISSB is mentioned in the proposed amended legislation
  • 77% of ASX100 companies already use GRI Standards
  • Australian accounting academics researching sustainability reporting have made a submission to Treasury objecting to elements of the draft legislation
  • Treasury is urged to review the consultation submissions to the AASB and ISSB itself and consult with other government departments

The Australian Treasury is consulting on whether and how to change legislation to allow the Australian Accounting Standards Board (AASB) to set “sustainability standards”. It would, of course, be completely appropriate for an accounting standards setting board to, say, incorporate climate change risks into asset valuations and perhaps also sustainability reporting standards, but only with the appropriate expertise on the Board. But whilst sustainability and climate change are skills that a person appointed to the Board may have under the proposals, there is no requirement for these skills to be represented on the the AASB.

Only the ISSB is mentioned in the proposed amended legislation. The explanatory materials state that:

The feedback [to an ASSB consultation] expressed a strong demand from Australian businesses, investors, financial institutions, and users and preparers of financial information, for Australian sustainability standards to align with the ISSB baseline.

I’m sure there was some strong demand from, say, the likes of the Chartered Accountants of Australia and NZ, but there were also many well argued, evidence based concerns. Many investors responding to the ISSB want a double materiality approach and the ISSB is only offering one side of that. The evidence that many also want the impact reporting side (i.e. reporting on the impact that the organisation has on society and the environment) is there in the KPMG finding that 77% of ASX 100 companies use GRI Standards. Accounting academics researching sustainability reporting are opposed to the ISSB’s conceptual framing (Adams and Mueller, 2022). Research shows it will work counter to sustainable development thinking and action.

You can read the submission to Treasury from Australian accounting academics researching sustainability reporting on the proposed legislative amendments here

Treasury should review the consultation responses to the AASB and ISSB itself. Many evidence based concerns are made. It should also consult other government departments with responsibility for protecting the environment, social justice, human rights and the SDGs.

Share this article

Speak Your Mind

*

Enter your email address to receive the latest posts