Confusion in ‘sustainability’ standards setting. What does that mean for reporting?

by Carol A Adams
What happens when sustainability disclosures are left to the judgement of reporting organisations? Most investors have an inkling at least, that in such cases sustainability disclosures are largely limited to what reporting organisations want you to know. Sometimes this involves deliberately misleading readers by partial reporting of bad news information – a trick to make readers think they are provided with everything they need to know.

Such investor inkling is backed up by three or four decades of scientific research by accounting academics in the field of sustainability reporting. (The research, and I edit one of the journals that publishes it, exposes poor reporting and looks at what drives reporting to make a positive difference to corporate action.)

Yet the IFRS Foundation and ISSB approach relies heavily on management judgement to inform ‘sustainability’ reporting. The exposure draft on general sustainability-related financial information expects management to make judgement calls on whether information is useful to investors, investor risk appetite and information that is financially material. So, business as usual then. 

The IFRS Foundation Trustees misled investors in its very first consultation question: Is there a need for a global set of internationally recognised sustainability reporting standards? (There is one already and what the ISSB is doing is not about sustainable development.)

So perhaps the ISSB was destined to flip-flop around trying to get support from regulators and investors rather than being guided by a vision as to what unique difference they want to make and what they want to achieve (apart from maximising support and dominating). 

Papers for the upcoming board meeting now refer to ‘sustainability-related disclosure’, dropping the word financial. The new title correctly indicates that they are neither dealing with financial nor sustainability matters.

But what exactly is it about?

The dismissiveness of the GRI in the first consultation led to a professional organisation’s version of an outcry. In response, the ISSB drew up a Memorandum of Understanding with GRI. However, while a staff paper notes that “IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards and GRI Standards can be viewed as two interconnected reporting pillars”, there seems to be little public determination to make that work (despite GRI publicly stating its willingness). Indeed, the ISSB is vague about whether it will instead veer into impact reporting now acknowledging the obvious difficulty of identifying when an organisation’s impact will become financially material. (Board papers continue to refer to the World Economic Forum’s metrics, not acknowledging they are a subset of indicators from GRI Standards).

The ISSB has ‘tentatively’ decided to apply the accounting concept of ‘reasonable and supportable information that is available at the reporting date without undue cost or effort’ to ‘sustainability-related’ reporting. A reporting organisation that isn’t already using the GRI Standards and the TCFD recommendations therefore has an out. (Those using GRI Standards and the TCFD recommendations are well placed to build on that work and report using S1 and S2.)

Which brings me to the question as to which body provides the ‘global baseline’? And who is whose building block? The ISSB is claiming it will provide the global baseline or starting point for sustainability reporting. (Never mind that they are 25 years behind GRI.) But we know that you can’t identify sustainability related risks and opportunities unless you know your impact on sustainability. The IFRS Foundation appear to have inadvertently acknowledged this in recommending “that the ISSB amend the sources of guidance to explicitly state that preparers may consider the GRI Standards to identify disclosures about sustainability-related risks and opportunities that meet the objectives of [draft] S1.”

The same paper indicates that some ISSB members don’t understand that impact reporting (as addressed in GRI Standards) is relevant to investors precisely because their development involves not only investors but also other stakeholders (that have a role in determining corporate value). This would explain why, rather than embrace the widespread use of GRI Standards “…some ISSB members expressed the worry that preparers would simply replicate GRI disclosures in fulfilling the requirements of IFRS S1”.

The puzzling question is why would any jurisdictional standard setter or stock exchange go along with such jiggery pokery [1]? And why would they support standards that are not informed by the scientific evidence in the field of sustainability reporting? 

Nations and investors need impact reporting, need what is covered in the GRI Universal Standards and all stakeholders (including investors) need reporting related to sustainable development to further evolve through GRI’s multi-stakeholder process. We also need reporting on financially relevant sustainability risks and opportunities. GRI and TCFD reporters will do this better. It makes no sense for a legislator to require risk reporting without also requiring GRI’s multi-stakeholder impact reporting. The EU knows this. Perhaps others will work it out. Who wants to be on the wrong side of history? Corporate reporters know they must be accountable to a wide range of stakeholders. Investors will continue to expect it. We need collaboration and co-operation.


[1] An English term meaning dishonest manipulation or nonsense

Share this article

Comments

  1. Farah Zamir says

    The article well coincides with my thoughts on the initiative of ISSB-IFRS in form of S1 and S2. I am not much convinced with the idea that despite well established sustainability Reporting initiatives such as GRI, why would companies need to follow S1 and S2, given the fact that these two build up on pre existing jurisdictions. I am still confused on thinking where this is taking the companies in reporting??

Speak Your Mind

*

Enter your email address to receive the latest posts