written by Carol Adams
Violence against women, rape, bungling of rape cases, sexism at work and in leadership have been high profile in the news in recent times. They are borne out of cultures that tolerate them.
In the context of an organisation, the starting point for doing something about inequity is revealing it – making it visible through data.
Data makes visible the extent of the problem and exactly where it lies.
There needs to be a good proportion of women at the top and on Boards – not just a few tokens – to influence the culture to facilitate change and inspire women at other levels. Data on the proportion of women at different levels of the organisation and on governance and senior committees and quantification the gender pay gap are standard disclosures included in the Global Reporting Initiative’s (GRI) G4 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines. In some countries such data has to be made publicly available by law, but it is often not widely communicated or in a way which allows problem areas to be identified.
Employers should provide such important performance data – not just for the organisation as a whole, but in a way which is meaningful to employees and broken down by business unit. It should be tabled at appropriate meetings, compared across business units and with previous years and benchmarked with other similar organisations where possible.
I’ve spoken at women’s events where participants who have experienced discrimination have felt isolated and helpless. They have not been aware of the extent of it or of any activity to address it.
I have seen well intentioned men shocked by such data become defensive. It can indeed be confronting. But once there is realisation and acceptance that something needs to be done, help can be found and change is already on the way.
CEDA’s recently published Women in Leadership: Understanding the Gender Gap, for example, contains a number of recommendations. Embedding Gender in Sustainability Reporting a joint project of the GRI and IFC developed through extensive stakeholder consultation and with the guidance of an Advisory Group (on which I served) provides examples of information that organisations can provide on performance and plans to improve it.
The failure to attract and retain good women can be as much, if not more, to do with process, institutional issues and culture rather than the manager who is doing the hiring. These quotes from corporate annual reports of the 1950s and 1960s demonstrate how societal norms contributed to the social and economic disadvantage of women – and how companies perpetuated them despite the clear economic disadvantage to the company in doing so. It was a time when men were explicitly appointed to manage and women to serve. A time when women were required to leave jobs upon marriage.
“It is now more important than ever that our younger men should be given every opportunity to develop fully their abilities and personalities. The proportion of men to total staff continues to decline and in consequence a greater proportion of male staff will be required to fill an increasing number of managerial and executive positions. The opportunities for our younger men are greater than they have ever been, and promotion will tend to come at an earlier age.” National Provincial Bank, 1956 corporate annual report
“We have opened a number of new branches during the year, including one in the West End of London under the management of a member of our women staff, Miss E. M. Harding. This interesting experiment has been hailed in some quarters as a portent, as indeed in a sense it is, but it may also be regarded as a natural and perhaps somewhat belated recognition that the holding of responsible posts in contact with our customers is no longer necessarily an exclusively male preserve.” Barclays Bank, 1958 corporate annual report
“The NP struck a blow for female equality in October last year with a new pay and promotion deal which enabled women staff members to take their place for the first time alongside men as branch managers…” National Provincial Bank, 1967 corporate annual
“…we also appointed… Miss P. Downs, who is personnel controller in charge of our female staff. We … congratulate Miss Downs in particular on being the first woman in our business to have attained top management level. For a business whose customers are predominantly women this seems a most logical step.” British Home Stores, 1968 corporate annual report
It is surely obvious to everyone now that such practices did not make business sense. Yet some 50 years on the existence of a gender pay gap for new graduates is inexplicable and in this context it should be no surprise to find pregnant women experiencing unacceptable discrimination.
CEDA’s Women in Leadership: Understanding the Gender Gap found that the association of leadership with male paradigms is a barrier to the appointment of women leaders – and indeed senior managers often don’t see value in attributes they don’t have. This is a big issue when women’s leadership styles have been found to differ from those dominant amongst men who fill the majority of senior positions.
Why it matters
The obvious benefit of being an equal opportunities employer is that you have access to the best staff. The risks of not providing equal opportunities for women and men go beyond losing out on talent. Dissatisfied, even frustrated and angry workers are not productive workers and poor equal opportunities practices and workplace cultures bring reputational and financial risk particularly where legal action is taken. This is bad for business, yet it is too often tolerated, even tacitly encouraged, to maintain the status quo in power balance. Diversity in gender and skills matters to providers of capital. It should matter to boards both in terms of ability to achieve strategy and to manage risks.
Ultimately for companies poor equal opportunities practice affects the bottom line. The costs to individuals affected by workplace discrimination, bullying and undermining are significant. The impacts are economic, psychological, social and emotional.
I started this piece mentioning (domestic) violence, rape and discrimination in the same sentence. Too many women have experienced male violence outside work and discrimination at work. Those experiencing domestic violence and rape are too often not taken seriously by authorities. These survivors are strong people who are entitled to be treated fairly and with respect at work.
We don’t have a complete picture of what goes on in the lives of colleagues and employees outside the work place. Improving equality in work practices will change our society and the way women and men experience life more broadly.
Employers have an ethical as well as a legal responsibility to ensure fair treatment at work. Workers and trade unions have a responsibility to hold them to account. This goes for discrimination on the grounds of race, age, disability and sexual orientation too.
Governments have a responsibility to facilitate change from the explicit gender inequalities of the 1960s to a society where women and men have equal opportunities.
Note:
The extracts from annual reports in this article were originally sourced for: Adams CA and Harte GF (1998). The Changing portrayal of the employment of women in British banks’ and retail companies’ corporate annual reports Accounting, Organizations and Society 23(8): 781–812.
Further reading:
Adams CA and Harte GF (2000). Making discrimination visible: the potential for social accounting Accounting Forum 24(1): 56–79
Grosser K, Adams CA and Moon J (2008). Equal Opportunity for Women in the Workplace: A study of corporate disclosure Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA): London.
Gender equality is a matter of sustainability Australian Financial Review 2009


Speak Your Mind