Carol Adams speaks with Paul Monaghan who led sustainability initiatives at the Co-operative in the UK for almost two decades.
1. Over the 18 years you have been leading sustainability initiatives at the Cooperative in the UK, what changes have you seen in business attitudes towards managing and being accountable for sustainability performance?
Yes, for nearly two decades I have been privileged to lead many of The Co-operative Group’s (based in the UK) excellent ethical and environmental programmes. The Co-operative Bank’s charismatic Managing Director, Terry Thomas, first drew me in to Europe’s largest consumer co-operative back in 1994. My brief was to embed ecological sustainability and to push forward what was already a radical agenda. It was a time of change and optimism. Political change and economic prosperity was in the air following the end of the Cold War era: John Major’s Conservative Government looked to be on its last legs in the UK; Apartheid was crumbling in South Africa and Bill Clinton and the Democrats had recently taken the Whitehouse.
More to the point, a new phase of corporate CSR was kicking-in; although in retrospect, it had a distinctly amateurish feel to it. Most of the opposite numbers I met from business were amiable old men at the end of their careers who had been shunted sideways from roles in human resources or public affairs. The first fairly traded and recycled products were emerging – but their quality was bloody awful. The first United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change had yet to meet.
There were no mobile phones or internet to speak of (these were wonders still largely restricted to the United States) – and imagine this: when you agreed to meet someone, you had to sort things out in advance and stick to your plans! Sustainability accounting was a nightmare. If you wanted information from other sites you suffered days of waiting via maddening internal mail, or were forced to stand over a fax machine and watch paper crawl out.
How things have changed. At the top end of CSR (and I know it’s not fashionable to say so) matters have improved fantastically. Today, Socially Responsible Investment has grown to become a $13 trillion global industry. Food Retailers are tripping over themselves to demonstrate who was the first to eliminate waste to landfill. Big energy users vociferously contest who has realised the better energy efficiency savings. Stakeholder Theory has removed the intellectual underpinning of those who say that maximising profits to shareholders is the best of all possible outcomes for society. Fairtrade, Forestry Stewardship Council (FSC) and Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) products are household names. Sustainability Reporting is the norm amongst larger businesses – transparency and league tables abound for everything from pesticides to refrigerant gas usage.
2. What role, if any, do you think business has in leading transformational change in society?
Despite its fuzzy, evolving definition and essentially contested status, CSR has grown in depth and numbers and is as strong as at any time in the last one hundred years. It has weathered the financial collapses of 2001 and 2008 amazingly well. Assuming there is light at the end of the current economic tunnel, it can be expected to get stronger still as business re-enters a profit growth phase. And (as the world’s resources become ever scarcer) we are finally witnessing an expansion in the small number of businesses who are taking sustainable development seriously.
I believe that the next phases of CSR and sustainability will involve (needs to involve!) leaders ‘Standing up for what’s right’ and ensuring that laggards and free riders don’t undermine the more progressive business models. Currently, business rarely sticks its head above the parapet to call for progressive legislative change: I’m talking about not just rewards for sustainable behaviour but penalties for unsustainable activity.
3. Of all your achievements which are you most proud of?
I’d like to think I’ve left The Co-operative in rude health as far as CSR and sustainability go. By hook and crook I built up one of the best resourced corporate social responsibility teams out there – some forty five people and over £10million of annual budget. They also have the essentials of strong foundations and robust architecture: namely, world class sustainability accounting, auditing and reporting and a leading edge revolving three-year Ethical Operating Plan.
4. You recently left the Coop – what do you plan to do next?
As I inferred earlier, the ‘business case’ for CSR will never be strong enough to support an isolated business in its competition against the unscrupulous. The progressive vanguard reaches a point where it can advance no further in its market without rendering itself uncompetitive. That is, unless the bar for what is the allowable lowest common denominator in society is raised. With the base reset, so is the bar of aspiration.
And that’s why, after nearly twenty years, I’ve left what is possibly one of the cushiest CSR jobs out there. I want to focus on helping more business become a vocal force for good – one that recognises that not all legislation is cumbersome red tape. The Co-operative has more than done its bit. It was out there in 2008 raising the issue of neo-nicotinoid pesticides and unconventional fossil fuels when most mainstream environmental groups wouldn’t touch the subjects (I was told that they were ‘too complex’). Now look, we have a two-year temporary embargo against certain neonics applications, and the possibility of a European Fuel Quality Standard that would effectively bar tar sands from the continent is under consideration.
The last thirty years have seen a hollowing out of Government across the world – together with a parallel reluctance of legislators to legislate. In order to plug this hole in societal governance, business is called on to work voluntarily and collectively to solve problems (even though this could see them prosecuted for acting like a cartel), with many politicians reduced to the role of mere award presenters. There is absolutely no way this approach can get us close to the sustainable society we know only to well we need to create. The next waves of CSR and sustainability heroes need to be (will be!) out and out campaigners. They will be brave, articulate and hark back to the great UK Victorian interventionists; the likes of Robert Owen, John Cadbury and William Lever. More significantly, they will act as a tipping point in the battle for a more sustainable economy. They will champion the Granny State – although Granny will need to be chemically enhanced with newfound powers of scientific literacy and evidence-based policy making!
Paul Monaghan is Director, Up the Ethics. He can be contacted on [email protected]



Speak Your Mind