written by Carol Adams
bankmecu is an IIRC integrated reporting pilot company. The 2012 annual report is the bank’s first ‘integrated’ report. It won the awards for best integrated and best online report in the 2013 Australasian Reporting Awards.
Reporting history
Up until 2010 bankmecu produced a separate annual and sustainability report. Reports dating back to 2005 are available on bankmecu’s website. Key strengths of the sustainability reports have been their transparency and accountability, innovation in online reporting (commencing with the 2009 report) and the provision of a short summary report (the long form of the 2007 and 2008 reports are 100 pages).
Previous sustainability reports have won the best sustainability report awards in the national ACCA and Australasian Reporting Awards.
Strategic objectives
bankmecu is Australia’s first customer owned bank. It aims to appeal to customers through competitive interest rates and its reputation for responsible practices and social and environmental sustainability aiming “to become the pre-eminent socially responsible banking brand in Australia”.
Research undertaken for bankmecu by Cannex, an independent Financial Services Research Group, Cannex, has found that bankmecu customers (the bank’s owners) are better off banking with bankmecu than the four major Australian banks.
bankmecu was been recognised as Australia’s most sustainable small company of the year by Ethical Investor in 2010. Its key Corporate Social Responsibility project is its Reconciliation Action Plan – “working with Reconciliation Australia to provide tangible actions for advancing the national effort to close the life expectancy gap between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians and other Australians”.
Ninety two per cent of bankmecu’s customers indicated that they are likely to factor in the reputation of the bank when making decisions about banking products and 70% indicated that renewable energy and vulnerable people were important issues (2012 annual report page 6).
What isn’t known, or at least not publicly, is whether these percentages would be so high if customers were not also better off with bankmecu. A reasonable assumption might be that they would be very considerably lower. This would indicate that balancing these strategic objectives is challenging – something not addressed in the report.
Aligning with the IIRC’s <IR> Framework
The purpose of this section is to consider how ‘integrated thinking’ and reporting might develop in light of the framework if it were to be followed. It analyses bankmecu’s 2012 report against the International Integrated Reporting Committee’s (IIRC) 2013 Consultation Draft of the International <IR> Framework. The framework is still in draft form and was not available at the time the report was prepared so gaps in the 2012 report are inevitable, particularly as the pilot companies lead the way with few examples to follow. It is not the intention here to provide any kind of assurance against the <IR> framework.
The report’s strengths include:
- The bank has achieved its main focus in developing its 2012 report of “aligning reporting structure and content with business strategy”. The report is brief and, in an important development of bankmecu’s reporting, appears (see point 2 below) to focus on material issues.
- The report (with supplementary information on the website) provides good coverage of the content elements (<IR> Framework pages 6 and 7) organisational overview and external environment, governance, strategy and resource allocation and performance.
- The online version allows the reader to create their own report by selecting specific sections to incorporate in a PDF.
The steps bankmecu might take to further align its reporting with the <IR> Framework are:
- A clearer articulation of the business model in the context of the six capitals (as far as they are material) in particular to increase the connectivity of information
- Process for determining material issues (particularly in the absence of assurance of covering this process) including the process for determining any material negative impacts on the capitals
- Content elements (<IR> Framework pages 6 and 7) which might be given more attention (subject to being material) are opportunities and risks, future outlook and business model
- Demonstrating stakeholder responsiveness
The website states that stakeholder engagement forms the basis of the annual report. Further information on stakeholder engagement activities is provided on the website here.
Point 1. above would involve some rethinking of the business model as depicted in the diagram on page 3. Human capital and social and relationship capital would seem to be particularly relevant to bankmecu’s business model. (The diagram on page 3 refers to ‘community’.) bankmecu is transparent about the proportion of women on the executive team and the Board, but does not articulate a link between its strategy (“to become the pre-eminent socially responsible banking brand in Australia”) and diversity or human capital more broadly.
Related articles on this website:
Next steps in integrated reporting: bankmecu
The banking sector and integrated reporting: focus on HSBC
Integrated thinking and integrated reporting
Understanding (how sustainability fits into) your business model
Materiality: financial reporting, sustainability reporting and integrated reporting
Integrated Reporting and the Six Capitals: What does it all mean?
Further reading:
Integrated reporting to walk more than the bottom line The Conversation


Speak Your Mind