written by Carol Adams
This article identifies some resources for preparers of integrated reports seeking to lead best practice and also for researchers. It identifies some of the many avenues for researchers seeking to contribute to the development of a new form of corporate reporting.
I put them together for the opening plenary of the 25th Asian Pacific Conference on International Accounting Issues held in Bali, Indonesia, 10th-13th November 2013. The conference had integrated reporting and sustainability reporting as its theme – a sign of changed times that this should be the theme for an international accounting conference. The first conference in 1989 was initiated by the The Sid Craig School of Business, California State University. Almost 300 people attended the Bali conference which was organised and sponsored by Universitas Indonesia.
After describing some of the features of integrated reporting and considering why it was important, my presentation focused on: resources for researchers; potential research topics; and, journal special issues.
Resources: Examples and analysis of Integrated Reports
Integrated reporting has been required by the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) in South Africa since 2010 and, whilst the requirements in the forthcoming International <IR> Framework will be somewhat different, South African integrated reports nevertheless provide some innovative examples and demonstrate that integrated reporting is a big step in the right direction. The following analyses of integrated reports on the JSE have been compiled by big four firms:
- PWC (2013) The value creation journey: A survey of JSE Top-40 companies’ integrated reports. Analysis of the Johannesburg Stock Exchanges top 40 companies’ Integrated Reports.
- EY’s Excellence in Integrated Reporting Awards. Surveys integrated reports from South Africa’s top 100 companies and top 10 public entities providing feedback on the reports of the top 10 companies.
- The IIRC’s Emerging Integrated Reporting Database The database allows identification of examples of reporting by content element, sector and geographic region. Over 100 companies around the world are now taking part in the IIRC’s pilot study.
- The CorporateRegister.com online database of company reports. The Corporate Register Reporting Awards now include a category for Integrated Reports.
Resources: the processes of developing the International <IR> Framework
Researchers interested in examining the processes of developing the International <IR> Framework may wish to consider:
- Individual responses to the IIRC’s consultation.
- The IIRC’s Technical Agenda Papers include:
- summaries of responses to the IIRC consultation
- potential technical projects.
- Commentaries in the press, blogs, etc.
- Statements by professional bodies, global intra-governmental bodies, guidelines/framework developers about (links with) <IR>.
Potential avenues for research – analysis of integrated reports
Analysis of integrated reports will contribute to the development of good practice. There is a need for analysis of:
- Quality of reporting on content elements especially: external environment; opportunities and risks; strategy and resource allocation; business model; future outlook.
- The concept of value and how organisations are defining value.
- Process of engaging stakeholders and identification of their interest.
- Process for determining materiality.
- Extent of ‘connectivity’ with the integrated report and across other communications.
- Media used for integrated reporting.
- Sector approaches to <IR> issues.
Potential avenues for research – case studies/surveys on processes of integrated reporting
The decision to prepare a first integrated report should lead to changes in: decision making processes; informal and formal communication processes; materiality and risk identification processes amongst others. Understanding the extent of these changes is important in considering the value of integrated reporting – itself an important factor in determining future guidance, policy and regulation. Understanding the factors which impact on the take up of integrated reporting is also important. Qualitative research approaches might be used in exploring:
- Process of determining materiality and identifying risks.
- Internal communications/ “integrated thinking”/ breaking down silos.
- Factors that determine uptake of <IR> including qualitative factors such as role of leadership/ leadership style.
- Changes to internal systems and processes on adoption of <IR>.
Other potential avenues for research
Other potential avenues for research include:
- Implications of <IR> uptake for sustainability management and reporting practices.
- Role and take up of <IR> in public and not-for-profit sectors.
- The political landscape – relationships with other frameworks, Stock Exchange requirements, national regulation.
- The impact of <IR> on decision making and outcomes.
- Analyst responses to integrated reports.
- Approaches to assurance of integrated reports.
Journal special issues
- Exploring capital and the notion of multiple capitals. Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal. Submissions close March 2014.
- Integrated reporting. Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal. Submissions closed.
- Subject to be determined. Journal of Financial Management and Accounting. Call not yet published.
Improving sustainability performance and reporting in Indonesia

- Professor Sidharta Utama, Universitas Indonesia, spoke about the ASEAN Corporate Governance Scorecard to promote sustainability reporting
- Ali Darwin, Chairman of the National Center for Sustainability Reporting, Indonesia which promotes sustainability practice and reporting facilitating the development of knowhow.
- Dr Rob Daniel, PWC Indonesia discussed the application of PWC’s Total Impact Measurement and Management approach as a framework to measure business impact for more sustainable growth.




Some further links to resources related to integrated reporting are listed here http://www.nfrcsr.org/international/reporting_guidelines/index.htm#_Toc364529418