Response to IIRC’s Consultation Draft of the International Integrated Reporting Framework

The IIRC’s Consultation Draft of the International <IR> Framework is a bold step forward in corporate reporting, but there are issues to address. This is a summary of those issues, priorities for the IIRC and the key strengths of the Consultation Draft.

Issues to be addressed in the framework

The submission (link at end) notes the following areas requiring to be addressed:

  • There should be more explicit acknowledgement that businesses deplete value as well as create it, particularly with respect to natural capital.  Lack of explicit acknowledgement will encourage lack of accountability for capital depletion.
  • There needs to be stronger encouragement to organisations to provide sustainability disclosures to key stakeholders other than providers of capital.  A  number of organisations are under the impression that they no longer need to do so.
  • Many organisations have an inadequate understanding of the interdependencies between the capitals and of the relevance of the capitals to their business model.  The IIRC could support work which promotes this.
  • With regard to stakeholder responsiveness, there needs to be more explicit acknowledgement that the materiality criteria for integrated reporting will not ensure that all material issues for key stakeholders are disclosed.  Some material concerns to many corporate stakeholders are not sufficiently acknowledged by many providers of finance.  Examples are the pressing global need to reduce carbon emissions and the gender pay gap. The framework could state that additional disclosures will need to be made either within the integrated report itself or in an additional report such as a sustainability report or special purpose report or online.

Priority areas for provision of further guidance

The submission identifies the following priority areas for the provision of further guidance by the IIRC:

  1.  How to move away from silo thinking towards integrated thinking, what it means and the steps that an organisation needs to go through to develop an integrated report.
  2. The links between integrated reporting, sustainability reporting, stakeholder engagement and risk.
  3. How to report on the relevance of the six capitals to the business model (though time is needed to allow for some innovation by reporters before meaningful guidance is developed).

Strengths of the Draft <IR> Framework

The submission (link at end) identifies the following strengths of <IR>:

  • <IR> stands out from other reporting frameworks in its emphasis on long-term thinking. Short-term thinking has contributed to significant negative environmental impacts which have damaged business reputations.  There are ample examples of companies plundering the environment and abusing human rights to make a quick buck.
  • The Framework’s requirement to provide information on an organisation’s strategy will encourage senior executives and boards to think long term.
  • Integrated reporting promotes an understanding of the trade-offs that are made across the six capitals in the process of creating value for providers of finance.  This will improve decision making.
  • The six capital concept and the concept of creating value through working with a broad range of stakeholders such as workers, customers, local communities and regulators encourages senior executives and Boards to think about performance more broadly than the financial bottom line.
  • Value creation goes beyond financial returns to providers of capital and considers the impact on the other capitals.
  • Value creation is about the long term.
  • The “integrated thinking” required to develop an integrated report will improve risk identification and decision making.

Link to submission to the IIRC on their Consultation Draft Framework made by Carol Adams: Final response to IIRC Consultation Draft Carol Adams

Related articles on this website

The banking sector and integrated reporting: focus on HSBC

Next steps in integrated reporting: bankmecu

Understanding (how sustainability fits into) your business model

Integrated Reporting and the Six Capitals: What does it all mean?

Integrated thinking and integrated reporting

Materiality: financial reporting, sustainability reporting and integrated reporting

Developing integrated thinking: an interview with bankmecu’s CEO Damien Walsh

Integrated reporting and directors’ responsibilities

ESG issues and business responses: an interview with Ian Woods, AMP Capital

Share this article

Speak Your Mind

*

Enter your email address to receive the latest posts